Season 1 finale should be higher and season 2 finale should be number 22 Years of Buffy The Vampire Slayer thank you for the memories shirt. Her having to kill Angel was so sad. I haven’t watched them in ages but I would put 2 above 5. Sure she died but seriously the show is called Buffy. We know it’s not permanent. Angel’s death felt more impactful, possibly because SMG is experiencing it. Personally, all the finales are equal awesomeness. I just couldn’t have a favorite. Even where buffy dies (twice) and angel dies. Let’s talk about episodes in general. I going to name categories and nominate a favorite episode. Everyone comments on their own categories and nominations.